A senior shipping executive says that Hong Kong - as well as other Asian ports - are falling behind their European counterparts in productivity terms.
Nicolas Sartini, group senior vice-president of Asia-Europe lines at French container line CMA CGM, said some European ports were 50 per cent more efficient at loading and unloading containers than those in Asia.
Sartini, who was in Hong Kong for the maiden call of the world's largest container ship, CMA CGM Marco Polo, said some Asian ports needed to "wake up and catch up with Europe".
Speaking on the bridge of the 16,020-teu (20-foot equivalent unit) ship, Sartini said Europe had traditionally been behind Asia in several areas, but he added: "Today, we get better productivity in Europe than Asia."
He explained that two European ports, Le Havre, where the line has its own terminal, and Hamburg, were capable of 150 container moves an hour whereas some Asian ports could only achieve 100 moves an hour.
A 2006 port benchmarking report by the Marine Department showed that in Hong Kong the number of boxes loaded and unloaded by a single crane averaged 36 moves per hour, with a peak rate of 40 per hour.
An October 2010 report by Dr Chen Tao, head of the Department of Logistics and Shipping Management at Taiwan's Kainan University, showed Hong Kong's quay efficiency was 140 box moves per hour. While the number of box moves was ahead of Shanghai and Ningbo, Hong Kong was behind Yantian and Qingdao.
Academics specialising in logistics that were quoted in the Chen study identified 13 factors that influenced terminal efficiency. These included terminal and ship size, the number of boxes being loaded and unloaded and the amount of cranes and other equipment deployed to support cargo operations and terminal management.
Sartini said there was a "big difference" in berth productivity between Asian and European ports. "We have to wake them up," he said of the Asian ports.
Eric Ip, group deputy managing director of Hutchison Port Holdings (HPH), was unperturbed by Sartini's comments. HPH, through Hongkong International Terminal, handles CMA CGM vessels in Hong Kong and deployed six massive cranes alongside CMA CGM Marco Polo to load and unload containers. These cranes had the capability to handle a total of 240 boxes an hour, while the ship spent less than 24 hours in the city before departing for Chiwan at 6am yesterday.
Source: scmp.com

Announcements
Job Offers
- Quality Assurance System Manager
- Junior Quality Control Technician
- Regional Sales Manager - Root, Switzerland
- Horticulture Specialist - Guelph (Ontario) Canada
- Technical Director - Brussels, Belgium
- Senior Maintenance Engineer - USA East coast greenhouse facility, location negotiable
- Greenhouse Assistant - Abbotsford (BC) Canada
- Technical Service Manager - remote, US based
- Chief agronomic / Head grower
- Chief Executive Officer



Specials more
Top 5 -yesterday
- Moroccan farmers are growing blueberries in the Sahara
- Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba brings technology into agriculture
- China and New Zealand discuss cooperation on new plant varieties
- "Next week, temperatures will increase and strawberry shortage shouldn't be as bad"
- Kiwifruit among the favorite fruits in Europe during the pandemic
Top 5 -last week
Top 5 -last month
Receive the daily newsletter in your email for free | Click here
Other news in this sector:
- 2021-01-20 New refrigeration systems help meet greater demand for cargo shipping
- 2021-01-20 Container shipping may encounter unprecedented "large-scale delays”
- 2021-01-20 APEDA initiative connects agri-export via direct flights from Lal Bahadur Shastri International Airport
- 2021-01-20 Chengdu-based Xianshenghuo raises US$92.5 million in Series A
- 2021-01-20 Container cargo rollovers at top 20 ports up 75% in December 2020
- 2021-01-20 Worldwide volumes of refrigerated trade reached a new high of 169.2 million tons in 2019
- 2021-01-19 Rwanda: High airfreight charges threaten horti export competitiveness
- 2021-01-19 Kenya: Technology to keep fruits and vegetables fresh longer
- 2021-01-18 “We are the only ones between Venlo and Hoogeveen with storage and transhipment capacity for fruit and veg”
- 2021-01-18 Businesses struggling due to freight cost increases in and out of New Zealand
- 2021-01-18 Dutch haulier, Van Duijn Transport, turns 75
- 2021-01-18 Record container throughput limits losses in 2020
- 2021-01-15 New managing director for APM Terminals Japan
- 2021-01-15 DSV builds integrated logistics centre in Stockholm, Sweden
- 2021-01-15 ‘Emergency’ measure planned at UK ports
- 2021-01-15 Fear of food shortages grows as EU truckers avoid UK ports due to Brexit
- 2021-01-14 India: Western Railway to transport fruits from South Gujarat
- 2021-01-14 Russian retailer Magnit delivering imported fruits to Moscow by rail
- 2021-01-14 Maersk, freight forwarders and shippers adapt to Damco dissolution
- 2021-01-14 "We knew it would snow, but we didn't expect anything close to this"